Best rated roofers in Carmel
Ranked by the share of Google ratings that are one or two stars — lowest first. 13 of the 19 roofers we list in Carmel have enough ratings to compare, against a typical Indiana roofer at 2.3%.
The 13 best rated roofers we list in Carmel
The top 2 are tied at 0% — none of their counted ratings is one or two stars. They share a position number because nothing separates them on the figure this list is ordered by; within the tie, more ratings counted comes first.
| # | Roofing contractor | Google average | Ratings counted | One and two star | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Myers Exteriorsroof replacement, gutters, siding5.0135 ratings0% one and two star(317) 204-2038 | 5.0 | 135 | 0%0 of 135 | (317) 204-2038 |
| 1 | Hoosier Roof Doctorchristmas light hanging, punctuality, quality work5.049 ratings0% one and two star(317) 992-5502 | 5.0 | 49 | 0%0 of 49 | (317) 992-5502 |
| 3 | UHQ Constructionsiding replacement, answering questions, gutter replacement5.0197 ratings0.5% one and two star(317) 661-2991 | 5.0 | 197 | 0.5%1 of 197 | (317) 661-2991 |
| 4 | Beard Roofing and Exteriorsroof replacement, gutters, gutter replacement5.0243 ratings0.8% one and two star(317) 689-7663 | 5.0 | 243 | 0.8%2 of 243 | (317) 689-7663 |
| 5 | Jax Roofing Companyinsurance claim assistance, hail storm damage, initial inspection4.9169 ratings1.2% one and two star(317) 441-4479 | 4.9 | 169 | 1.2%2 of 169 | (317) 441-4479 |
| 6 | Robert Stevens Roofingroof and gutters, new roof installation, quick response4.962 ratings1.6% one and two star(317) 722-1844 | 4.9 | 62 | 1.6%1 of 62 | (317) 722-1844 |
| 7 | Red Bird Roofingthorough inspection, insurance claims, thoroughness4.9271 ratings2.6% one and two star(317) 593-9742 | 4.9 | 271 | 2.6%7 of 271 | (317) 593-9742 |
| 8 | Element Roofinggutters, insurance claim assistance, siding4.9175 ratings2.9% one and two star(317) 790-2175 | 4.9 | 175 | 2.9%5 of 175 | (317) 790-2175 |
| 9 | Shadybrook Roofing, LLCquick response, insulation installation, garage insulation4.853 ratings3.8% one and two star(317) 599-8744 | 4.8 | 53 | 3.8%2 of 53 | (317) 599-8744 |
| 10 | Blue Ladder Roofinginsurance claim assistance, insurance coordination, storm damage repair4.8413 ratings3.9% one and two star(463) 222-5211 | 4.8 | 413 | 3.9%16 of 413 | (463) 222-5211 |
| 11 | Eads Roofing & Exteriorsinsurance claim assistance, gutters, roofing crew4.8149 ratings4.0% one and two star(317) 343-2941 | 4.8 | 149 | 4.0%6 of 149 | (317) 343-2941 |
| 12 | Mister Quik Home Servicesinspection, estimate development, insurance advice4.7211 ratings7.1% one and two star(317) 480-4012 | 4.7 | 211 | 7.1%15 of 211 | (317) 480-4012 |
| 13 | AmeriPro Roofingroof replacement, answering questions, insurance claim assistance4.5258 ratings12.4% one and two star(317) 316-8551 | 4.5 | 258 | 12.4%32 of 258 | (317) 316-8551 |
How this order is decided
One sort, on one figure: the share of a roofer’s Google ratings that are one or two stars, lowest first. Both numbers behind it — how many ratings are one or two stars, and how many there are in total — are printed beside every name, so you can check the order against the page and the page against Google.
Roofers whose share prints the same figure share a position number, because they are tied on the only thing being ordered. Within a tie the one with more ratings behind it is listed first; if that is equal too, the higher star average, and then alphabetically. Those last steps only ever separate roofers the figure itself cannot, and they exist so the order is the same every time the site is rebuilt rather than shuffling.
There is no Roof Warden score, no editorial pick and nothing anyone can pay for. We only rank roofers we list with at least 40 ratings, because below that a single unhappy customer swings the percentage by more than the differences we would be ordering on. That leaves 6 roofers on this page unranked — which says nothing about their work, only that there are too few ratings to sort on.
This is not every roofer in Carmel. We list 19, captured from public Google listings, and rank the 13 with enough ratings to compare. Treat it as a shortlist to check, not a complete market.
All 19 roofers we list in Carmel · Best rated across Indiana