First Choice Exteriors

The only one or two-star review we hold for First Choice Exteriors.

• 1 out of 5Nick2 years ago

  My experience with First Choice was very poor. My insurance company approved my claim in August 2023, but the project wasn't completed until June 2024. During this entire time, they removed a section of my siding on the front of my house to try to get a match (I do not know why they took it from here and not the back or detached garage). The report to match the siding took months because they lost a piece of the siding apparently. Even when they received the matching report they did not send it to the insurance company, so I had to ask consistently to get the report. Then I was the one who sent it to the insurance agency. Then I was the one who had to go to the siding store to take pictures of the potential matching siding and I had to send those to the insurance companies. I had to work with insurance to get the matching coverage without any help from First Choice even though they noted they would handle that. Throughout the entire time I heard excuses for the delays. The excuses or lies they told me: - "Lost a piece of siding" which caused significant delays. - "I was sick over the weekend" - used as an excuse to cancel a meeting. - "I will get the report to insurance today" - they didn't follow through, and I had to do it weeks later. - "I will pick up some examples and take pictures for matching siding this week" - they never did this. - "I am going to swing by today and take a few pictures with a digital measuring app to find matching siding" - they never did this, so I ended up doing it myself. - "The measurements on the garage did not work" - another delay before they finally returned for new measurements. - "The desk adjuster is out of the office for a couple of days." - After asking for an update: "I plan on calling Tracy on Monday" - no further update for two weeks. - "I have been in and out of ER and doctor's appointments this week" - another two weeks passed with no communication. - "I am out of the country so I could meet three weeks later." - "I can

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

• roof replacement21
• insurance claim assistance12
• gutter replacement9
• hail damage repair9
• thorough inspection6
• exterior work6
• smooth process4
• efficient crew4
• skylight replacement2
• responsive to questions2
• quick and efficient job2

14 more of the 86 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.

• 5 out of 5Stephen Hearna month ago

  We've been very happy with First Choice Exteriors. They did a great job on our roof in 2015, helped us with a long-overlooked problem with our insurance coverage for that job, and checked our roof again after a recent hail storm and …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

• 5 out of 5Paul Fisher3 months ago

  We used First Choice in 2021 to replace the roof on our home and pool house. They were phenomenal in working through the insurance process and getting us on the right track. Have had to call a few times over the years for some info for …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

• 5 out of 5John Simon5 months ago

  I cannot thank First Choice Exteriors enough for their hard work. I was in need of a roof replacement after my insurance company informed me that they were no longer going to provide coverage on my roof. I wasn’t prepared to replace my roof at the time, but after I reached out to First Choice Exteriors, they were able to offer me a financing deal that solved my worries. Once it came to completing the work, I was blown away by their production team’s attentiveness to the project. They even managed to solve some of the insulation problem I had before the new roof. I won’t hesitate to call First Choice Exteriors in the future for any exterior projects. They handled the roof replacement professionally every step of the way and I’m confident they’d be able to do the same for others. Huge thank you to the team at First Choice Exteriors!

• 5 out of 5Terry Brennan6 months ago

  Our roof sustained damage by hail and was replaced by First Choice Exteriors. We are very satisfied with the project. Their work crew showed up when expected and worked efficiently. The workers covered our shrubs and landscaping features …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

• 5 out of 5Gary Thomsen8 months ago

  First Choice Exteriors installed gutter guards and did a quick and efficient job at a good price. While up on the roof, they noticed hail damage. Preston took charge and fought with State Farm to get us a new roof. After 2 months of negotiations, State Farm approved the roof and the job was completed less than a week later. We paid only our deductible. I would recommend First Choice for any exterior work you need completed.

• 5 out of 5Michelle Heath9 months ago

  Preston was very helpful & knowledgeable, he explained & always responded when I called with questions. Dave was also helpful with scheduling all my projects. I would recommend this company for anyone who needs home exterior work. They are very professional & meet the customer needs.

• 5 out of 5Tom Brennana year ago

  We had a great experience using First Choice Exteriors to install gutters on our house. Preston did an amazing job listening to what we wanted and then providing options and choices we could do. The quote was very complete and professional …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

• 5 out of 5Grant Bernardya year ago

  We just used First Choice for a window replacement project at our home, we had been waiting for years to move forward with the project and decided on them because they had a very fair price and great customer service, we were able to work …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

• 5 out of 5Sarah Colea year ago

  First Choice took care of everything. They replaced my roof, installed gutter guards, and replaced my skylight. Being able to have it all done through one company made the entire storm damage process so much less stressful. They worked …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

• 5 out of 5Brian Groffa year ago

  First Choice did a great job in our roof and siding. They also installed our gutters as a separate project. Well done and very professional!

• 5 out of 5Dresden Passa year ago

  I highly recommend First Choice and cannot speak highly enough of their team. They will be my first call if myself, a family member, or a friend is in need of exterior work. Thank you First Choice!

• 5 out of 5The Gutter Doctora year ago

  Thank you Mark and family for your time and help!

• 5 out of 5Gutter Doctora year ago

  Very professional! Really helped me out. Great work!

• 5 out of 5Kathryn Schaefera year ago

  We had such a great experience. Easy from start to finish and the roof looks beautiful!

Happy Father’s Day to all the amazing dads out there. We want to give a special shoutout to the dads in the trades who work hard every day for their families while passing down their knowledge and experience to the next generation. There is something special about the example trade dads set every day. The work you do. The problems you solve. The pride you take in doing things the right way. Those lessons leave a lasting impression. Well done, dads. Today, we’d like to introduce you to our dad, Mark Willier. The lessons he taught us go far beyond roofing. He taught us the value of hard work. He taught us to treat people right. He taught us that your reputation is earned over time and that doing the right thing always matters. Happy Father’s Day, Dad. Thank you for everything you’ve taught us. — Preston & BrookeJun 21, 2026Learn more

• Warranty offered

  “…Customer Satisfaction Guarantee Your satisfaction is paramount to us.…”

• States years in business

  “…More than 26 years later, First Choice Exteriors still…”

• States a founding year

  “…Trusted Roofing Company Since 1999 Your First Choice in Roofing and…”

• Free estimates

  “…Davis Brus Homeowner Request a Free Estimate Thank you! We’ve received your…”

• Family owned

  “…Since 1999 First Choice Exteriors is a family-owned roofing and exterior company that’s…”