Roofing contractor
Fair And Square Roofing LLC
12165 Metro Pkwy #23, Fort Myers, FL 33966
- Google average
- 4.6
- Ratings counted
- 100
- One and two star
- 10 of 100(10.0%)
- Florida median
- 2.5%
The first three are Google’s own figures for Fair And Square Roofing LLC, read on 18 November 2026; the share is of every rating Google has counted, not of the review texts on this page. The median is ours — the middle figure among the Florida roofers we list with enough ratings to compare.
Rating breakdown
| 5 | 86 | 86% | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | 4 | 4% | |
| 3 | 0 | 0% | |
| 2 | 4 | 4% | |
| 1 | 6 | 6% |
Higher than most — the typical roofer in Florida sits at 2.5%. A higher share is a reason to read the critical reviews below, not a verdict.
The critical reviews
The one and two-star reviews, first. These are what a star average hides, and they are the reason this page exists.
All 4 of the one and two-star reviews we hold for Fair And Square Roofing LLC, most recent first.
- 1 out of 5Ron KolumbusEdited 3 years ago
We hired Fair and Square Roofing to tarp our roof after Hurricane Ian damaged our shingles for $1,500. They arrived just before sunset and I was not comfortable having them tarp my roof in the dark. At sunset I requested that they leave it for another day as they could injure themselves and I didn't feel they could do a competent, professional job in the dark. Agai st my wishes they remained on the job and completed it after sunset, and needless to say it tore off in a week. Attached are some photos of the missing/ torn tarp they installed. Fair and Square never attached boards to the ends of the tarp and they didn't reinforce the tarp to the roof with boards. They quickly nailed the tarp to the roof which easily gave way to the wind. Other homes on our street hired other companies and have professionally installed secure tarps.
- 1 out of 5Anthony4 years ago
Reached out to Fair and square to come out to my office building in hopes to get a quote for a new roof. After speaking to a customer service rep and setting up the appointment, I received a confirmation email. The day came for the estimate …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
- 1 out of 5Pam Plote6 years ago
Never showed never called back
- 1 out of 5Jen.6 years ago
Honestly, I would've loved to have given them a chance to change my mind, however I called to schedule an appointment, I received a call from a gentleman named Dan back on 02/20/20 and made an appointment for the 26th at 10am. A little past 10am, I got a call asking to reschedule the appointment for later in the day due to the weather, however I had another appointment that afternoon and told them to just come by when I was not home the next day, the 27th and send me a quote with their findings or to call me to discuss any issues. As of today, 03/05/2020 I have yet to hear back from anyone, have not received a quote or call back. Still not sure if they ever even came out. I have since gotten two other roofing companies to come out instead to quote me. I was somewhat disappointed as I had hoped to go with this company due to their "Google Guarantee" partnership, but seeing as I could not even get them to quote me or contact me, I've decided to go elsewhere. The beginning should be the easy part, if they are struggling to even contact me back to sell me their services, I can't imagine how they would be able to keep up with the construction, permitting and dealing with my insurance in a timely fashion.
What reviewers keep mentioning
Topics Google extracted from this business’s reviews, with how many mention each. These are words that appeared in reviews, which is not the same as a service the business sells.
- hurricane ian8
- insurance requirement5
- polite crew3
- tile roof2
- metal roof2
- fast completion2
- gutter repair2
- responsible staff2
- deadlines2
- permitting2
Other reviews we hold
14 more of the 75 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.
- 5 out of 5Don SappEdited 9 months ago
Great Price and great work Great company
Reply from the business
Thank you for your positive feedback, Don! We're glad to hear that you were satisfied with our pricing and quality of work. Your support means a lot to us!
- 5 out of 5John DembeckEdited a year ago
Following Hurricane Ian (2022), just getting a roofer to answer the phone or not putting us on an endless waitlist was challenging. Rusty, the owner, not only picked up the phone himself but promptly sent background info and spent phone …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
- 5 out of 5Va year ago
They took time to explain and answer questions providing the most affordable estimate. I like the quick responses from Fair and Square Roofing representatives. They repaired areas of the roof that needed attention and did it well including …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
- 5 out of 5E E (edichka777)a year ago
Great technician, great workmanship!!!
- 5 out of 5Roger Browna year ago
We had the pleasure of working with Kevin Frost and can relate that the service provided was professional from the get go....the crew was excellent... polite and hard working. Highly recommend!
- 5 out of 5Mary C. NiesEdited a year ago
This company has met expectations of professional performance from start to finish. They always answered my questions quickly and addressed any of my concerns. Will not hesitate to use them if necessary and recommend them highly!
Reply from the business
Thanks for your review best-roof-repair-in-fort-myers
- 5 out of 5Jose Echevarriaa year ago
Highly recommend!! Honest and great communication. Best price and work was done in a timely fashion. Thank you
Reply from the business
Thank you for your wonderful review, Jose! We're thrilled to hear that you had a positive experience with our communication and service. Your recommendation means a lot to us! We look forward to working with you again in the future.
- 5 out of 5Jeff JarvisEdited a year ago
Great guys to work with, our rental homes roof was wrecked by Ian and the team at Fair and Square did a fantastic job replacing everything.
- 5 out of 5Yuriy Kostyuka year ago
They did a Great Job! Very fast and quality service!
- 5 out of 5tudor rusua year ago
Mike did a very good job. Easy process and fair price.
- 5 out of 5Ed DonnelleyEdited 2 years ago
Andre Barry, Catalina Isles, I cannot say enough about this company and the job they did. I signed a contract of Friday and on Monday a truck was dropping off materials. The workforce …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
Reply from the business
Thank you so very much, Sir for all of your kind words. ! Truly appreciated. You have been a fantastic customer to work with. Let us know if you need anything else roofing related.
- 5 out of 5CM Auto Repair2 years ago
Pressure quality
Reply from the business
Hello. Thank you, but we do roofing only. You can contact me at (239)292-00-29 if I am reading this wrong. Thank you, Rusty.
- 5 out of 5Teresa V2 years ago
Fair and Square roofing did a fantastic job! We hired them after our prior contractor left us with only a partial metal roof. To ensure our estimate was accurate Shawn sent the metal install crew to our home to determine what needed to be done to correct the previous installation and finish our roof properly. Fair and Square handled all of the permit changes, metal order, and completed our roof faster than we had anticipated. Shawn was easily available to answer questions. Castro and his team worked hard (sometimes 12 hour days) to complete our roof. They came when they said they would and delivered. Highly recommend!
- 5 out of 5Sean Czarnomski2 years ago
I hired Fair and Square Roofing to repair a roof leak. This Company is extremely service oriented. The Saleman, Kevin answered my service call promptly and was able to diagnose the problem and sent Castro and Juan to overser the repairs. I commend the staff that they sent. They did a neat and thorough job and roof doesn't leak. I would not hesitate on recommending this company based on their fair price for the repairs and most of all for their honesty and integrity . Thank you for a job well done.
What Fair And Square Roofing LLC says about itself
Taken from the business’s own website. We have not checked any of it. These are quotes, not credentials — a roofer writing “licensed and insured” on their homepage is not evidence that they are.
Free estimates
“…Book a free consultation to discuss our six different types of…”
Their site also states: states a founding year.
Other roofers in Fort Myers
Ranked by how many ratings Google has counted.
| Roofing contractor | Google average | Ratings counted | One and two star | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Roman Roofing Incinspection, responsive staff, new roof4.81,138 ratings5.4% one and two star(239) 458-7663 | 4.8 | 1,138 | 5.4%62 of 1,138 | (239) 458-7663 |
| Crowther Roofing and Coolingtile roof, courteous staff, estimate4.6507 ratings10.7% one and two star(239) 579-3476 | 4.6 | 507 | 10.7%54 of 507 | (239) 579-3476 |
| Resolute Roofing LLCnew roof, courteous staff, quick completion4.9499 ratings2.8% one and two star(239) 488-2113 | 4.9 | 499 | 2.8%14 of 499 | (239) 488-2113 |
| Target Roofingpolite staff, estimate, leak repair4.7389 ratings6.4% one and two star(239) 332-5707 | 4.7 | 389 | 6.4%25 of 389 | (239) 332-5707 |
| Roof Smart of SW Floridaestimate, metal roof, personable staff4.7284 ratings7.0% one and two star(239) 549-7663 | 4.7 | 284 | 7.0%20 of 284 | (239) 549-7663 |
| First Service Roofing & Constructionroof replacement, answering questions, hurricane repairs4.7220 ratings5.5% one and two star(239) 652-5784 | 4.7 | 220 | 5.5%12 of 220 | (239) 652-5784 |
Where this page comes from
Every figure above is Google’s, captured on 18 November 2026. The star average and the 100 ratings behind it are counted by Google across all of its reviews. The review text on this page is a sample — we hold 100, of which 75 have any text — and it is not everything Google shows.
Roof Warden does not verify licenses, bonds, insurance or workers’ compensation cover, and nothing on this page should be read as though we had. Confirm those directly with the contractor and with your state or provincial licensing body before you hire anyone.