Skip to content
Roof Warden

Roofing contractor

Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors

3624 E Newport Rd, Gordonville, PA 17529

Listed under Lancaster, PA

Google average
4.9
Ratings counted
351
One and two star
5 of 351(1.4%)
Pennsylvania median
1.8%

The first three are Google’s own figures for Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors, read on 24 September 2026; the share is of every rating Google has counted, not of the review texts on this page. The median is ours — the middle figure among the Pennsylvania roofers we list with enough ratings to compare.

Rating breakdown

4.9
351 ratings
Google’s profile shows 348
How the 351 ratings break down, from five stars to one
5
34498%
4
21%
3
00%
2
00%
1
51%
1.4%of these 351 ratings are one or two stars (5)

About typical — the typical roofer in Pennsylvania sits at 1.8%. A higher share is a reason to read the critical reviews below, not a verdict.

The critical reviews

The one and two-star reviews, first. These are what a star average hides, and they are the reason this page exists.

All 3 of the one and two-star reviews we hold for Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors, most recent first.

  • 1 out of 5AC ShipmanEdited 3 years ago

    We called them today as we had a couple of siding pieces come off due to the very high winds. Someone came by fairly quickly and gave us an estimate of almost $1,800 to put back the 2 siding pieces. Wow! They also charged us $129.95 for coming to the house today and didn't even bother to at least nail down the other siding pieces that most likely will come off in the meantime as the wind continues. So we paid them for the "pleasure" of coming by and give us that outrageous estimate. Btw, I followed up with Ray who insisted that today's call was a "service call" when in fact it was just an estimate call since no service was performed whatsoever. This company is a joke! We did call someone else and they came by, gave us a free estimate, and their fee is less than 20% the fee that "Best Contracting" was trying to charge us. Do yourself a favor and call other companies. Any company with this kind of shady practice should not be in business. Update: The company ended up not charging us the $129.95.

    Reply from the business

    We are sorry you were unsatisfied with our service. We tried reaching out several times to discuss your concerns. The price given was not for a repair only but to remove the siding from the peak down to the issue area, then replace the siding from that damaged area up to the roof peak. Best has repaired siding for many years, our concern with paying someone to just pop on a new piece or two will likely result in that piece blowing off in another wind storm as that siding must be hung tighter from that spot up to the very peak, and not just a spot repair. We have refunded the service fee for diagnosing the issue and hope your matter can be quickly resolved.

  • 1 out of 5Ripper Magoo3 years ago

    They mailed me a letter saying I had hail damage from recent storms made arrangements for Brandon to stop by on Friday 8/26 and on 8/19 I get a text saying I'm here and no one is home so I called him and said it was next Friday so I asked him if I needed to be there for him to look he said no and he would get back to me now it's the 29 of August and still no word I even called the place of business and I left a message and still no call back

    Reply from the business

    We sincerely apologize for your frustration! Our representative did show up at the scheduled appointment time. However when he arrived nobody was home. Brandon then called you to discuss the inspection over the phone but accidentally failed to follow up with you after completing the inspection. We sincerely apologize for failing to properly follow up after the inspection. However we are always just a phone call away and have a full time secretary that answers phones during (normal business hours) Brandon has since followed up with you and apologized for this slip up. We are not perfect but do strive to serve our community the best we can.

  • 1 out of 5heirloombEdited 4 years ago

    Our our entire roof was replaced by this company and we now have other issues that were created by this company causing us to have to have the roof replaced not even 2 months after. Missing drip edges, other parts of the job not done at all and to get them to commit to fixing the damage they they did to our home during the installation of our entire roof is not even something they are willing to do. The solutions given void warranty and not to mention trying to get the warranty information due to you from them is non existent. Forget using this company they will also replace your stuff with lesser items that are not in kind replacement. 5-4-2022 update. This company now a year later still refises to take care of any of the numerous repairs that are needed for their poor workman ship that caused other problems we never had with this roof in and on many areas. They wont even take care of venting they from a bathroom they covered with the new roofing. Many many issues and non responsive Literally they wanted to take the money and run

    Reply from the business

    Given our history of being known in our community as being honest and fair, and seeing our nearly one hundred - 5 star reviews it is clear we care well for our customers. We feel that the work was done in a workmanlike manner and Best Contracting believes that all work was done pursuant to contract. We are not perfect but work tirelessly to make right any mistakes on our part. Allegations against Best Contracting were made for excuse for non-payment. We respectfully disagree with the assertion being made.

What reviewers keep mentioning

Topics Google extracted from this business’s reviews, with how many mention each. These are words that appeared in reviews, which is not the same as a service the business sells.

  • thoroughness43
  • courteous staff42
  • siding repair39
  • gutter replacement16
  • hail damage repair11
  • shingle replacement7
  • extended warranty6
  • fascia replacement5
  • clean work area4
  • shutter installation2

Other reviews we hold

14 more of the 321 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.

  • 5 out of 5jason gooch6 hours ago

    Professional, very good at what he does. I would recvomend him any time

  • 5 out of 5Amy Davis6 hours ago

    Dave is the best service guy i have encountered at my workplace!! Thank you!

  • 5 out of 5Steve Woratyla2 days ago

    Best contracting did an amazing job on our roof replacement. Great communication. Fair pricing. Very reliable. Highly recommend.

  • 5 out of 5Alisha Sheetsa week ago

    Great job fixing the torn off fleshing on my roof. Polite, professional and does quick work! Thanks so much!

    Reply from the business

    Thanks Alisha! We appreciate the kind words and are glad we could get the flashing repaired quickly. Thanks for choosing Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors!

  • 5 out of 5David Bastadya week ago

    Dave was on time and very professional. Excellent experience.

    Reply from the business

    Thanks David! We appreciate the great feedback. Glad Dave was able to take care of the siding repair. Thanks for choosing Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors!

  • 5 out of 5Lisa2 weeks ago

    I live in a rental community where Best was hired to come replace our roof. Our rental managers never gave us warning, and subsequently some things got messed up. Ray, one of the owners, personally came back to go above and beyond in order …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Lisa, Thank you so much for your thoughtful 5-star review! We truly appreciate your understanding. We're glad Ray was able to address your concerns and make things right. Providing quality workmanship and standing behind our work is very important to us. Thank you again for your kind words and recommendation. We wish you all the best in your next home, and if you ever need exterior services in the future, we'd be honored to help! – The Best Contracting Team

  • 5 out of 5Amanda Dorsey2 weeks ago

    Mike was amazing, kind, and thorough during the time of my quote. He explained the issues, the necessary repairs/replacements, and all rationale. He was patient and made me feel comfortable. I really wish I could proceed with his team but …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    Amanda, thank you so much for taking the time to share your experience! We’re thrilled to hear that Mike was able to provide a thorough explanation, answer your questions, and make you feel comfortable throughout the process. While we understand your current project wasn’t the right fit for our services, we truly appreciate you considering Best Contracting and keeping us in mind for any future needs. We’re grateful for your kind words and wish you the very best with your window replacement project!

  • 5 out of 5David Sallard2 weeks ago

    Dave (great name, BTW😉) from Best Contracting was efficient and super friendly! He quickly diagnosed the problem and fixed it so it doesn't happen again. Not that I *want* any future issues, but if there are, he is a pleasure to work with! …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    Dave, thank you so much for the great review! We’re glad our technician "Dave" :) was able to quickly identify the issue, make the repair, and help prevent it from happening again. We truly appreciate your kind words about his professionalism and friendliness. We’ll be here whenever you need us in the future—hopefully only for routine maintenance!

  • 5 out of 5Courtney Bellmann3 weeks ago

    Best Contracting did an amazing job replacing the fascia on our house that came down during the storm a few weeks ago! Dave was very thorough and we really appreciated him talking us through everything. 10/10 recommend!

    Reply from the business

    Thank you so much, Courtney! We're glad we could help after the storm and get your fascia repaired quickly. We'll be sure to pass your kind words along to Dave—he takes pride in making sure every homeowner understands the process and feels confident every step of the way. We truly appreciate your recommendation and thank you for trusting Best Contracting with your home!

  • 5 out of 5Bob Quillen3 weeks ago

    I have l known Myron & his crew at Best Contracting for years. Spiritually lead Leader. I love their values, work ethic, attention to detail & communication during the process. Highly recommend to Family & Friends

    Reply from the business

    Bob, thank you so much for your kind words and for your support over the years. It truly means a lot coming from someone who has known us for so long. We strive to honor our values in the way we serve our customers, and we're grateful you recognize our commitment to quality, communication, and attention to detail. Thank you for trusting Best Contracting and for recommending us to your family and friends. We sincerely appreciate your friendship and support!

  • 5 out of 5Robert Hicksa month ago

    I could not be more delighted with the work that Dave from Best Contracting did for me. Communicative and punctual up front, showed up in a very nice truck with all the needed equipment on site. That's the way professionals do things and …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    Robert, thank you so much for the kind review and recommendation. We’re glad Dave was communicative and punctual, showed up prepared, and got your project knocked out quickly with fair pricing. We really appreciate you considering Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors for roofing, siding, and exterior work.

  • 5 out of 5Michelle Sotomayora month ago

    The job was done super well, they included a follow up with pictures. I'm so impressed.....

    Reply from the business

    Thank you, Michelle! We truly appreciate your kind words and the opportunity to install your new CertainTeed roof. We’re glad you were impressed with the quality of the workmanship and our communication throughout the project. Providing detailed photo updates is one way we help homeowners feel confident every step of the process. Thank you again for trusting Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors with your home. We hope you enjoy your new roof for many years to come!

  • 5 out of 5Harrisa month ago

    Excellent service, detailed work, very complete, wonderful communication throughout the process, would highly recommend

    Reply from the business

    Thank you, Harris! We truly appreciate you trusting us with your new roof and gutters. It means a lot to hear that you were happy with our communication, attention to detail, and overall experience from start to finish. We work hard to make every project as smooth and stress-free as possible. Thank you again for your recommendation and for taking the time to leave us such a thoughtful review. We hope you enjoy your new roof and gutters for many years to come!

  • 5 out of 5John Pulcinellaa month ago

    We couldn’t be happier with our experience working with Best Contracting! From our very first conversation to the final walkthrough, the entire process was seamless and professional. Their communication was outstanding every step of the way. They were always responsive, answered every question promptly, kept us informed throughout the project, and made us feel confident that everything was under control. It’s rare to find a contractor who is this organized, honest, and easy to work with. The craftsmanship and attention to detail truly exceeded our expectations. Every member of the team took pride in their work, and it shows in the finished product. The final result turned out even better than we imagined, and we’ve received so many compliments already. If you’re looking for a contractor who delivers exceptional quality, communicates consistently, and genuinely cares about customer satisfaction, I can’t recommend Best Contracting highly enough. We are already planning to work with them again in the near future.

    Reply from the business

    John, thank you for taking the time to leave such a thoughtful review. It was a pleasure working with you, and we’re grateful for the trust you placed in our team. Hearing that our communication, professionalism, and attention to detail exceeded your expectations means a great deal to us. We hope you enjoy your freshly updated exterior for many years to come. If there’s ever anything you need, we’re always here to help. Thank you again for choosing Best Contracting. We truly appreciate your support.

The latest post from this business

Posted by Best Contracting Roofing & Exteriors to their own Google profile 6 months ago. Their words, not ours.

🍂 Is your roof ready for fall weather? Late summer is one of the best times to schedule a roof inspection before colder temperatures, storms, and heavy weather arrive later in the year. Best Contracting helps homeowners identify roofing concerns early through professional inspections, preventative maintenance, and repair services designed to improve long-term roof performance. 5 hours agoLearn more

Other roofers in Lancaster

Ranked by how many ratings Google has counted.

Other roofers we list in Lancaster
Roofing contractor
The Exterior Companyroof replacement, answering questions, insurance claim assistance4.82,230 ratings3.8% one and two star(717) 621-5097
Joyland Roofingestimate, courteous staff, gutter replacement4.9760 ratings2.5% one and two star(717) 906-7791
Greenawalt Roofing Companyroof replacement, gutters, siding4.9671 ratings2.1% one and two star(717) 283-4721
Zimmerman's Roofingknowledgeable staff, thoroughness, courteous staff4.9581 ratings1.5% one and two star(717) 351-7928
George J. Grove & Son Inc.professional staff, window replacement, siding installation4.9430 ratings2.3% one and two star(717) 393-0859
Moser Roofing Solutionsthorough inspections, courteous staff, leak repair4.9276 ratings1.1% one and two star(717) 690-2581

All roofers in Lancaster →

Where this page comes from

Every figure above is Google’s, captured on 24 September 2026. The star average and the 351 ratings behind it are counted by Google across all of its reviews. The review text on this page is a sample — we hold 351, of which 321 have any text — and it is not everything Google shows.

Roof Warden does not verify licenses, bonds, insurance or workers’ compensation cover, and nothing on this page should be read as though we had. Confirm those directly with the contractor and with your state or provincial licensing body before you hire anyone.