Skip to content
Roof Warden

Roofing contractor

GMR Metal Roofs Ohio

6384 Proprietors Rd, Columbus, OH 43085

Listed under Hilliard, OH

Google average
4.5
Ratings counted
52
One and two star
7 of 52(13.5%)
Ohio median
2.0%

The first three are Google’s own figures for GMR Metal Roofs Ohio, read on 18 November 2026; the share is of every rating Google has counted, not of the review texts on this page. The median is ours — the middle figure among the Ohio roofers we list with enough ratings to compare.

Rating breakdown

4.5
52 ratings
How the 52 ratings break down, from five stars to one
5
4587%
4
00%
3
00%
2
12%
1
612%
13.5%of these 52 ratings are one or two stars (7)

Much higher than most — the typical roofer in Ohio sits at 2.0%. A higher share is a reason to read the critical reviews below, not a verdict.

The critical reviews

The one and two-star reviews, first. These are what a star average hides, and they are the reason this page exists.

All 6 of the one and two-star reviews we hold for GMR Metal Roofs Ohio, most recent first.

  • 1 out of 5Ryan StiversEdited 9 months ago

    GMR (Garvin Metal Roofs at the time) installed our Tilcor metal roof in 2020. In the years since, we've had numerous issues with leaks, though all were "repaired" under warranty. A year ago we started to experience another leak, but now GMR is unreachable. GMR Ohio has seemingly vacated their offices. So now I'm left dealing with GMR PA, GMR NY, and GMR FL. Experiencing the same issue as others - Calls not being returned, calls straight to voicemail, and blocked numbers. Here's the usual call flow: 1. You'll likely get voicemail. They will not return the call based on the voicemail. 2. If your number is not blocked at this point, on one of the rare instances where you do get someone, they will either tell you they'll refer you to warranty for a call back (unsurprisingly they will not actually call back) or they will transfer you, and you'll sit on hold indefinitely. 3. If you attempt to call back yourself, you will either get an immediate disconnect or a busy signal. Your number is likely blocked. 4. You can confirm the above by calling from a different number. Try google voice or something if you don't have one. You can maybe get through and restart the entire process from beginning to end, ad nauseam. It seems as though GMR (PA, OH, NY, FL), Garvin Metal Roofs, Premier Homeowner Solutions, whatever business name the Garvin brothers are operating under, has no intention of honoring your existing warranty.

  • 1 out of 5Nicka year ago

    Having issues and can’t get a return call… if I do get a live person on the phone they just send me to a voicemail and that’s the end of it I have never heard back for them in several months and have called several times a week for months and left messages on occasion. I wish I knew then what I know now about this Garvin Metal Roofs. Good luck if you ever need warranty work.

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

  • 2 out of 5XiziX3 years ago

    Roof looked amazing. 2-3 weeks means 2-3 months. They did an amazing job though. Mexicanw work really hard. I work with them everyday because I do construction for wexner Zuckerberg and bezos. There was enough material left over to build another house. Most people don't realize that what is delivered to the job site is theirs. They did a great job on the roof though. It looks really amazing. Looks amazing. A little scammy. Charged me for WAY to much material and labor because I know.

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Just a little confused - was not aware you had any issues with the roofing project at all? We always over ship materials to avoid any delays during the roof installation. This is stated on the roofing agreement and with the supply chain as it is right now - we do everything we can to make sure when your roofing project is started - it is completed in a timely manner with no delays. We have spoken personally and if their is anything I can do to explain this better and change you overall experience - feel free to reach out anytime.

  • 1 out of 5Michelle3 years ago

    If I could give no stars I would. Saw this vendor at the home and Garden Show in Columbus. Gave them our info. They called at the beginning the week and scheduled an appointment with us. We waited all day.They never showed up or called. So, I don't care how good you are if you are so disrespectful of my time, I don't want your company.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Michelle, I am sorry to hear about your experience with us. I have trie to locate your file but it is hard to do so with only a first name. I would like to discuss this with you if you are open to it - I can be reached at 614-344-1464 Mike N.

  • 1 out of 5Paul FeduchakEdited 4 years ago

    Nightmare process. Multiple sales and customer service employees lied. I was told an active leak would be tarped while waiting for installation. That didn't happen. Installation timeline was completely false. Still do not have paperwork on warranty. (for all I know the warranty is a scam to get the sale) Pleas note, the company finally did make things right. This was the direct result of the general manager Anthony Riccio. Once he took over the process I was not told any more lies and he communicated what was being done to fixed what was promised. Although all problems were not able to be fixed, he let me know, and why they could not be fixed. In my opinion, Anthony Riccio should get an 8 or 9 star review just for fixing the mess that was my roof installation. He is the one positive I had with Garvin Metal Roofs.

  • 1 out of 5Tom Hocker6 years ago

    I called for an estimate. Lady on line said they don't do inspections. I said I would contact someone else. I called back got an answer service. I wondered if they do estimation without seeing the roof. She called me back said put words in my mouth about wanting two more years out of the roof. I just needed an estimate That's all. Terrible, rude juvenile communication skills here . I would never trust this company.

What reviewers keep mentioning

Topics Google extracted from this business’s reviews, with how many mention each. These are words that appeared in reviews, which is not the same as a service the business sells.

  • metal roof12
  • courteous crew5
  • installation crew5
  • new gutters4
  • new roof look3
  • quick installation3
  • roof quality3
  • beautiful material3
  • standing seam2
  • installation time2
  • daily cleanup2

Other reviews we hold

14 more of the 48 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.

  • 5 out of 5Larry Maiera year ago

    They install fairly priced metal roofs on residential and commercial buildings.

    Reply from the business

    Thank you for your positive review! We're glad to hear that you found our pricing fair and that you appreciate the quality of our metal roof installations for both residential and commercial buildings. We look forward to serving you again in the future!

  • 5 out of 5B Jon2 years ago

    I was nervous to get a new roof because of how big of a decision it is, and because of the level of importance of a good roof, but I’m very happy that I ended up going with GMR. They were very flexible and patient with me. I have a …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Brandyn - thanks so much for the review! It was a pleasure working for you and your roof looks amazing!

  • 5 out of 5Daniel Nelson2 years ago

    Amazing work done! From the start of the project to the end, very efficient and professional! Also cleaned up throughout the whole process. Highly recommended

    Reply from the business

    Hi Dan - thanks so much for the review! Your roofs looks amazing!

  • 5 out of 5Kory Sensky2 years ago

    Hands down the best overall home improvement project we have every had in 25 years of home improvement projects. Josh set expectations properly from the beginning, delivered an ontime installation working around a tough weather schedule, and managed the project communication from start to finish. The installation crew was on time every day, were all very professional and friendly, and provided an excellent quality installation. Thank you all very much for a great home improvement project, we could not be happier with the quality and delivery from Garvin Metal Roofs!

    Reply from the business

    Hi Kory - thanks for taking the time to post this review! Your new roof looks beautiful and we are always excited to hear about our customers experience!

  • 5 out of 5Erick Anderson2 years ago

    Josh was professional, patient, helpful and above all else the most communicative out of all the folks I received estimates for my roof from. Josh was extremely patient, helped me find the best solution for our roof, personally oversaw that the job was being done right, and left us with a solid feeling that we had chosen the right man for the job in getting our roof done. Would 100% recommend to anyone seeking someone competent to get their roof done. Josh was honest and helpful throughout the entire process! Went from having the worst roof on the street, to the very best! Thank you!

    Reply from the business

    Hi Eric - thanks for the kind words about Josh - he is the best! Always good to hear about our customer's experience!

  • 5 out of 5Diane Hoenig2 years ago

    Its been on since 2020, it's beautiful and not an issue since installation! Thank you.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Diane - thanks so much for the review! Your roof looks amazing!

  • 5 out of 5Richard Karsmizki2 years ago

    I was impressed on how quickly the job went and how professional the people were. Everything was cleaned up afterwards and everything that had to be moved out of the way was moved back

    Reply from the business

    Hi Richard - thank you for posting about your experience!

  • 5 out of 5Karl Schedler2 years ago

    Our new roof was installed last week. The crew arrived as promised and finished the job in three days. They were courteous and seemed very professional. I asked a couple of questions, and they responded quickly and politely. The roof looks great, and they cleaned up everything when they left. It rained two days later and there was no sign of a leak. I have every reason to expect that the roof will last for 40 years. I will recommend them to my friends.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Karl - thanks so much for the review! Your roof looks absolutely beautiful!

  • 5 out of 5Remys Dad3 years ago

    Our experience with Garvin was excellent from beginning to end. Josh, the Garvin representative, was totally knowledgeable about every aspect of the roofing job. We had several estimates but Josh made the difference for Garvin. They even …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Stuart - thanks so much for the review! Your roof looks beautiful!

  • 5 out of 5Brandon Ricketts3 years ago

    We had standing seam installed after our roof was totaled by wind damage. Overall we had a good experience with Garvin and the roof looks great. We even had 80mph wind gusts not long after installation and she held up like a champ. With the 40yr warranty this should be the last roof I ever buy (for this home). The team we worked with was responsive and friendly. Overall a good experience.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Brandon - thanks for taking the time to post about your experience! We've got you covered for the next 40 years!

  • 5 out of 5Maggie Arwood3 years ago

    It's that last roof I'll ever need! Great value for a roof that will last 50 years. Fast, high quality work and good communication. I would use them again

    Reply from the business

    Hi Maggie - thanks so much for the review! Your roof looks amazing!

  • 5 out of 5Lee Hayes3 years ago

    We wanted a quality roof that would not require a lot of maintenance and looked correct for the age of our house. Therefore we chose a metal roof that looks like shingles. We love it and still get compliments on it after more than a year since it was installed. The crew who did it were professional and cleaned up after themselves daily. It's not the cheapest but I believe it's one of the best especially with their warranty. It will outlast me for sure.

    Reply from the business

    Hi Lee - thanks so much for the review! You're roof looks great!

  • 5 out of 5Patricia Connor3 years ago

    I first saw Garvin Metal Roofs at the annual spring home show in Columbus, OH, in 2022. I had a sales rep come to my house and he was prepared with measurements from aerial shots. So, I had light-colored high reflectivity Garvin Metal Roof installed on my house in March 2022. I think the installation crew did a great job. So far, so good! The biggest difference is the temperature in the upstairs of my Cape Cod style home. It got very warm in the summer before the roof installation and even with the a/c on. The reduction in the summer temperature is dramatic. It’s now usually only a couple of degrees warmer than downstairs. Mission accomplished!

    Reply from the business

    Hi Pat - thanks so much for the review! Happy to hear you are seeing the benefits of having a metal roof installed!

  • 5 out of 5Ruth Dumolt3 years ago

    They did a great job very pleased with the service I would definitely recommend them .

    Reply from the business

    Hi Ruth - thanks for posting about your experience!!

What GMR Metal Roofs Ohio says about itself

Taken from the business’s own website. We have not checked any of it. These are quotes, not credentials — a roofer writing “licensed and insured” on their homepage is not evidence that they are.

  • Financing available

    “…Corporate TOTO12 Elush Service Provider Financing Options Trade-in Traveller’s Reservation…”

Other roofers in Hilliard

Ranked by how many ratings Google has counted.

Other roofers we list in Hilliard
Roofing contractor
MK Exteriors, Inc.siding repair, reasonable pricing, gutter replacement5.0355 ratings0.6% one and two star(614) 556-3535
Best Roofing and Siding Companysiding replacement, product selection, gutter replacement5.0311 ratings0.6% one and two star(614) 924-7721
Imperial Roofing and Contractingroof replacement, insurance claim assistance, thorough inspection5.0311 ratings1.0% one and two star(614) 263-7663
Mighty Dog Roofing of Columbus Westroof replacement, kind staff, insurance claim assistance4.9260 ratings1.5% one and two star(614) 810-8863
DTE Roofingroof replacement, insurance claim assistance, inspection5.0118 ratings0% one and two star(614) 971-6028
Arrow Roofing and Sidinggreat work, estimate, efficient3.7114 ratings32.5% one and two star(614) 777-7663

All roofers in Hilliard →

Where this page comes from

Every figure above is Google’s, captured on 18 November 2026. The star average and the 52 ratings behind it are counted by Google across all of its reviews. The review text on this page is a sample — we hold 52, of which 48 have any text — and it is not everything Google shows.

Roof Warden does not verify licenses, bonds, insurance or workers’ compensation cover, and nothing on this page should be read as though we had. Confirm those directly with the contractor and with your state or provincial licensing body before you hire anyone.