Roofing contractor
Cotterman & Company, Inc.
1745 Atlas St, Columbus, OH 43228
Listed under Hilliard, OH
- Google average
- 4.5
- Ratings counted
- 17
- One and two star
- 2 of 17(11.8%)
- Ohio median
- 2.0%
The first three are Google’s own figures for Cotterman & Company, Inc., read on 24 September 2026; the share is of every rating Google has counted, not of the review texts on this page. The median is ours — the middle figure among the Ohio roofers we list with enough ratings to compare.
Rating breakdown
| 5 | 14 | 82% | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | 0 | 0% | |
| 3 | 1 | 6% | |
| 2 | 1 | 6% | |
| 1 | 1 | 6% |
Higher than most — the typical roofer in Ohio sits at 2.0%. A higher share is a reason to read the critical reviews below, not a verdict.
The critical reviews
The one and two-star reviews, first. These are what a star average hides, and they are the reason this page exists.
All 2 of the one and two-star reviews we hold for Cotterman & Company, Inc., most recent first.
- 1 out of 5Reina Guillen4 years ago
Good
- 2 out of 5Becca Cramer9 years ago
After a quote and subsequent completed work totaling $4,000, the roof continued to leak. The crew returned to fix the leak. We were surprised a week later to receive another invoice for more than $400. They told us that the reason for additional cost was due to third party damage, but nobody had been on the roof other than Cotterman employees. We waited for the rain, sure enough, the roof leaked, this time from a puncture. We were again sent an invoice for close to $300. Again, the damage was said to be 'third party damage' and again, nobody had been on the roof except Cotterman employees. Cotterman did void the 3rd invoice after some discussion. We were asked never to call them again.
What reviewers keep mentioning
Topics Google extracted from this business’s reviews, with how many mention each. These are words that appeared in reviews, which is not the same as a service the business sells.
- communication2
Other reviews we hold
9 more of the 11 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.
- 5 out of 5jm ga year ago
Professional, transparent, knowledgeable, and excellent communication. I would highly recommend.
- 5 out of 5Zenios Zenios2 years ago
Cotterman Roofing has been a trusted vendor of our company for the past few years. Their professionalism and attention to detail is what sets them apart of the competition. I would recommend them without hesitation.
- 5 out of 5Brody Flowers4 years ago
Fast and professional
- 5 out of 5Taesan Kim4 years ago
Very professional and great communication
- 5 out of 5Katlyn Johnston4 years ago
great roofing
- 5 out of 5Brayden Cotterman4 years ago
Absolutely amazing services.
- 5 out of 5Jorden Cao4 years ago
They were amazing.
- 5 out of 5Zenios Zenios8 years ago
Cotterman & Company have been reliable, professional and of the highest quality.
- 5 out of 5Gary Baker8 years ago
Having dealt with many roofers Cotterman is a different class! Great work at a great price!
What Cotterman & Company, Inc. says about itself
Taken from the business’s own website. We have not checked any of it. These are quotes, not credentials — a roofer writing “licensed and insured” on their homepage is not evidence that they are.
24/7 emergency call-out
“…Inspections / Preventative Maintenance 24-7 Emergency Repair Service Safety…”
Mentions the BBB
“…Columbus Better Business Bureau Button National Roofing Contractors…”
Other roofers in Hilliard
Ranked by how many ratings Google has counted.
| Roofing contractor | Google average | Ratings counted | One and two star | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MK Exteriors, Inc.siding repair, reasonable pricing, gutter replacement5.0355 ratings0.6% one and two star(614) 556-3535 | 5.0 | 355 | 0.6%2 of 355 | (614) 556-3535 |
| Best Roofing and Siding Companysiding replacement, product selection, gutter replacement5.0311 ratings0.6% one and two star(614) 924-7721 | 5.0 | 311 | 0.6%2 of 311 | (614) 924-7721 |
| Imperial Roofing and Contractingroof replacement, insurance claim assistance, thorough inspection5.0311 ratings1.0% one and two star(614) 263-7663 | 5.0 | 311 | 1.0%3 of 311 | (614) 263-7663 |
| Mighty Dog Roofing of Columbus Westroof replacement, kind staff, insurance claim assistance4.9260 ratings1.5% one and two star(614) 810-8863 | 4.9 | 260 | 1.5%4 of 260 | (614) 810-8863 |
| DTE Roofingroof replacement, insurance claim assistance, inspection5.0118 ratings0% one and two star(614) 971-6028 | 5.0 | 118 | 0%0 of 118 | (614) 971-6028 |
| Arrow Roofing and Sidinggreat work, estimate, efficient3.7114 ratings32.5% one and two star(614) 777-7663 | 3.7 | 114 | 32.5%37 of 114 | (614) 777-7663 |
Where this page comes from
Every figure above is Google’s, captured on 24 September 2026. The star average and the 17 ratings behind it are counted by Google across all of its reviews. The review text on this page is a sample — we hold 17, of which 11 have any text — and it is not everything Google shows.
Roof Warden does not verify licenses, bonds, insurance or workers’ compensation cover, and nothing on this page should be read as though we had. Confirm those directly with the contractor and with your state or provincial licensing body before you hire anyone.