Pro Plus Roofing

All 3 of the one and two-star reviews we hold for Pro Plus Roofing, most recent first.

• 1 out of 5Dustin RomeroEdited 3 months ago

  2025: So...this has been a ride...3 months ago I got a quote and their "system" was supposed to put me on the schedule, and it dident. So after waiting a month, I called them and talked to someone who said they would get me in that …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

  Reply from the business

  We appreciate you sharing your perspective, though we are surprised by this feedback as we have no record of a project or service agreement at this address. At Pro Plus Roofing, we are committed to honest and reliable service—values that have earned us the trust of local insurance agents and fellow contractors. Since no work was actually performed, we'd appreciate the chance to speak with you directly to clear up any confusion regarding our scheduling system.

• 1 out of 5Timarie Javier6 years ago

  Never got back to me. I called twice, on the 27th & 29th of April, and left a message both times asking to call me back. Needless to say, I have not heard back from anyone!

  Reply from the business

  We appreciate you bringing this to our attention, Timarie. Reliability is a cornerstone of Pro Plus Roofing, and we have no record of these inquiries in our system. If there was a technical error on our end, we would certainly like to make it right. Please contact our office directly so we can assist you.

• 1 out of 5denise randall7 years ago

  Don't even bother calling these people. I call for an estimate and a roof job. Basically was told unless I just hire him,, he won't come out. No thanks!! To respond to your response. I did hire local Someone who wants my business and is thankful for it. I made the right choice by not hiring you. So thank you for showing your true colors sir. I'm thankful I don't have to deal with your "company".

  Reply from the business

  There are several hundred insurance adjusters and one of me. I simply can not be evrywhere at once. Thank you for choosing someone else as it frees up more time for us to be able to get to people that want to work with their local professionals. There are enough storm chasers around to assist people that are just "looking for bids" we do apologize that there are so many people wanting to stay local and we simply can not get to them quick enough. We are doing everything that we can but refuse to sell our name out to storm chasers like some other "local" companies do.

• insurance paperwork assistance7
• insurance assistance7
• siding4
• skilled workers2
• shingle repair2
• thoughtful owners2
• garage door replacement2
• hail damage2
• timely completion2
• roof appearance2
• fast work2
• working crew2

14 more of the 42 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.

• 5 out of 5Leah Stevens2 weeks ago

  Pro Plus always provides professional and quality work as well as a great experience. I am a real estate agent who has had the pleasure with working with Pro Plus many times for work and personal exterior needs and and they have always done such a great and quality job! They are absolutely worth your call!!

  Reply from the business

  Leah, thank you — this means a lot coming from someone who works with as many contractors as you do. It's been a genuine pleasure being your go-to for your clients' exteriors and your own place, and we don't take that trust lightly. Agents who send us their clients are the backbone of a local, family-run business — we'll always show up and do it right. Thank you for the confidence in Pro Plus.

• 5 out of 5Terri Fryea month ago

  Pro Plus Roofing was a good choice for replacing our roof and repair our siding due to a major hail storm last June. Jason Sikkenda was our project lead and he came several times to get the photos needed to help the insurance company see …

  Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

  Reply from the business

  Terri, this means the world to us — thank you. That June hail storm put a lot of families through it, and we're so glad we could get your roof replaced and siding repaired while keeping the insurance side as smooth as possible. If you'll let me brag on Jason for a second: he's our youngest son, and getting to watch the next generation step into our family business is one of the things we're proudest of. He doesn't manage from a clipboard — he's been hands-on with siding installs and up on the roofs alongside our crews when we were short-handed. That's exactly why he can walk a homeowner, and an insurance adjuster, through what needs to happen, in what order, and why. A review like yours tells us he's doing it right. Thank you for trusting Pro Plus — and for recommending us. — Nate & the Pro Plus family

• 5 out of 5Kaylee Humphriesa month ago

  Thankful for Nate and his crew! We were trying to get our shop tinned before we left for vacation and time was working against us so we called for help! They did a great job on the roof and tin, were very quick and had some pretty handy equipment to get the job done before we left.

  Reply from the business

  Thank you so much, Kaylee! We know you were up against the clock trying to get the shop tinned before vacation, so we're glad we could jump in and get the roof and tin done in time. It was a pleasure working with you — enjoy your trip, and give us a call anytime you need us! — Nate & the Pro Plus crew

• 5 out of 5Don Kramera month ago

  Professional, friendly, knowledgeable & helped with insurance. Highly recommended!

  Reply from the business

  Don, thank you — this means a lot. I'll be honest: this one wasn't easy. Two different adjusters denied your roof before we got it approved. When we know a claim is legitimate, we don't quit — and I'm really glad we got you taken care of. Thank you for trusting Pro Plus.

• 5 out of 5dwayne heafnerEdited a month ago

  Pro Plus Roofing did an incredible job. They showed up right away, got the work done fast, and the quality is excellent. They were incredibly easy to work with—complete professionals who were polite, respectful, and focused on getting the job done without any unnecessary small talk or sales pitches. Highly recommended!

  Reply from the business

  Dwayne, thank you for the great review. We appreciate you noticing the crew’s professionalism and straightforward approach. Glad we could get it handled quickly and make the process easy.

• 5 out of 5Matt Drakea month ago

  Nate and the crew have done a few roofs for me! Went above and beyond to get my grandma‘s roof, taken care of great business!!

  Reply from the business

  Thank you for sending her our way, it worked out well as I don't do many roofs in Riverton but it couldn't have been better timing to catch her project while we were doing another roof over there anyway. Thank you Matt.

• 5 out of 5Benjamin Opfara month ago

  We had an excellent experience with Pro Plus Roofing. The crews were on time and completed the job in a quick turn-around time without skimping on quality. Both the roofing crew and gutter replacement crew were friendly and cleaned up the area without damage to our landscaping. Nate and Tana were excellent to work with and we highly recommend contracting their services.

  Reply from the business

  Mr. Opfar, thank you for the kind review. That was a steep roof, and I’m proud of how quickly and safely the crew got it done. We appreciate you trusting Pro Plus Roofing with the project.

• 5 out of 5Jamie Knickerbocker2 months ago

  Nate is great!! As a real estate agent I have to call Nate and his crews multiple times per year for different services that they offer. They are always very responsive and professional. They get the job done right every time in a timely manner! Will continue using and recommending them to everyone!

  Reply from the business

  Jamie, thank you — that means a lot coming from someone who works with as many people as you do. We love taking care of you and your clients, and we'll always make time to get your listings and referrals handled right and on schedule. Thanks for the continued trust and for spreading the word — it genuinely keeps our crews busy. — Nate, Pro Plus Roofing

• 5 out of 5Denise Bradford3 months ago

  When we realized our roof needed replaced we still drug our feet as we did not want to deal with the mess or hassle but after contacting pro plus roofing an visiting with Nate an Tana we said lets get it done . O boy did they ever . Work was done quickly very professionally what a great experience what a great company. Thank you pro plus roofing .

  Reply from the business

  Thank you Denise!! We are grateful that you trusted us for the repairs to your lovely home. And I will always be grateful to Rick for swooping in and digging my car out of a snowdrift that 1 time! What an honor to have such caring neighbors. Please feel free to call us, at any time, if you have any questions or concerns.

• 5 out of 5Leah Garvin4 months ago

  If I could rate a 10 star review I would. Such a great company. My roof looks so beautiful. Nate and Tana are amazing.

  Reply from the business

  "Thank you so much for the incredible 10-star shoutout, Leah! We are thrilled to hear that you love your new roof. I’ll be sure to share your kind words with Nate and Tana—they take great pride in their work and will be so happy to know they made such a positive impact. We appreciate your business!"

• 5 out of 5Terrence Quinna year ago

  I would give 10 stars if I could!! Best roofing business in Gillette and Sheridan!! Tana and Nate are committed to making your roofing experience fantastic!! Call them today!!!

  Reply from the business

  Mr. Quinn, thank you so much for the kind words and the 10-star shoutout! It truly means the world coming from you. We still have such fond memories of the years our kids were in school under your leadership—you were always so great to work with. We’re honored that you chose us for your roofing project here in Gillette. I’ll be sure to tell Nate and Tana you said hello; they’ll be touched by your support. Wishing you all the best!

• 5 out of 5Carol F.a year ago

  Pro Plus Roofing is very professional contractor. Easy and helpful to work with, and clean. ((They used a magnet over my yard and porch to make sure no roofing nails were left behind). I would highly recommend this business. Carol Foster

  Reply from the business

  Thank you for the kind words, Carol! It was a pleasure working with you. We know how important it is to leave a home exactly as we found it, which is why we always do that extra sweep with the magnet. We’re so glad you noticed! Thank you for the high recommendation and for choosing us for your roofing needs.

• 5 out of 5Jaime Keucka year ago

  As a Realtor I know the importance of finding a good, reliable, honest and skilled contractor. When we personally put a home under contract, the first thing I did was have Nate go inspect the roof. It did end up needing replaced. Pro Plus not doing a new roof would have been the only deal breaker for me. I wanted a quality roof that I wouldn't have to give another thought to. I can't recommend Pro Plus enough!

  Reply from the business

  Jaime, thank you so much for the incredible review! It’s always a privilege to work with you and the team at 411 Realty. We know that in real estate, timing is everything—especially when a closing date is on the line. We make it a top priority to shift things around and get those inspections and installs done quickly for your clients. Knowing you trusted us with your personal home is the highest compliment we could receive. Looking forward to many more projects together!

• 5 out of 5Edward Mazur2 years ago

  Kris and his crew came over to our house for a roof inspection since we’d been facing a few issues. It turned out that the recent hail had left a few shingle marks on it but thankfully, the team knew how to repair it too. They fixed it in no time. We’re very grateful!!

  Reply from the business

  We truly appreciate the feedback, Edward! Dealing with hail can be stressful, but our team takes pride in being able to diagnose and repair damage efficiently. It’s great to hear that Kris provided the service you were looking for. Thank you for choosing Pro Plus Roofing & Construction!

No roof is too high, and no detail is too small for our crew! 🛠️⛪ We recently took on the challenge of roofing a steep, 3-story historical church right here in Sheridan. Projects like this require exceptional safety measures, precision craftsmanship, and a deep respect for historical architecture. From navigating the extreme pitches to preserving the building's timeless character, the Pros handled it all with care. Whether you have a historic treasure or a modern home, trust the local experts to get the job done right. Give us a call at (307) 682-0889 or visit proplusroofing.net to schedule your free estimate today!Jun 7, 2026Call now

• Licensed

  “…I'm a Realtor (307) 682-0889 Licensed & Insured 24/7 Emergency Service…”

• Insured

  “…Realtor (307) 682-0889 Licensed & Insured 24/7 Emergency Service Family Owned…”

• Warranty offered

  “…don't have to Maximum Coverage Guaranteed We've helped thousands of…”

• States a founding year

  “…Most Trusted Roofing Company Since 1999 | Gillette, Sheridan, Newcastle Pro…”

• Free estimates

  “…Storm Damage Projects (307) 682-0889 Free Estimate Rated 5 Stars by Wyoming Families…”

• 24/7 emergency call-out

  “…(307) 682-0889 Licensed & Insured 24/7 Emergency Service Family Owned &…”

• Mentions the BBB

  “…★★★★★ Google Review BBB A+ BBB Accredited A+ Rating since 2013 Licensed &…”

• Family owned

  “…& Insured 24/7 Emergency Service Family Owned & Operated Why Choose Pro Plus?…”