Roofing contractor
Gouge Quality Roofing
4159 Fosnaugh School Rd SW, Amanda, OH 43102
Listed under Lancaster, OH
- Google average
- 4.9
- Ratings counted
- 209
- One and two star
- 2 of 209(1.0%)
- Ohio median
- 2.0%
The first three are Google’s own figures for Gouge Quality Roofing, read on 24 September 2026; the share is of every rating Google has counted, not of the review texts on this page. The median is ours — the middle figure among the Ohio roofers we list with enough ratings to compare.
Rating breakdown
| 5 | 204 | 98% | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 | 3 | 1% | |
| 3 | 0 | 0% | |
| 2 | 0 | 0% | |
| 1 | 2 | 1% |
Lower than most — the typical roofer in Ohio sits at 2.0%. A higher share is a reason to read the critical reviews below, not a verdict.
The critical reviews
The one and two-star reviews, first. These are what a star average hides, and they are the reason this page exists.
All 2 of the one and two-star reviews we hold for Gouge Quality Roofing, most recent first.
- 1 out of 5Douglas BlairEdited a year ago
Of the several contractors that I interviewed for an enhanced siding/insulation/gutters installation, Caleb Gouge and company presented and performed measurably above every competitor. Amid lingering snow, ice and more, company personnel surveyed our home, listened carefully to our specific and demanding requirements, and said this: "We can do exactly what you want." Not only did they tailor the work to some specific little things, but with excellent workmanship and a still reasonable price. Of course there were a few problems. Like a top notch organization should, they regrouped, bounced back and got it done. We are pleased, satisfied, and will give hearty recommendation to any who seek the affordable best in the area. ** Edit, about a year later. A few midline errors and mistakes became evident that required correction. The process of getting the contractor to make good was rough, and I must withdraw my Goodwill recommendation. Before you sign and pay on your contract, be sure to have clarity on how such workmanship issues will be handled. I supplied clear photo documentation of their mistakes, and was all but shown the door. Very displeased.
- 1 out of 5E S2 years ago
They came to my house to review the job, they seemed nice and told me how good their company was and promised me a quote within a week, then they ghosted me. Not very professional, caused me to burn almost two weeks waiting for them.
Reply from the business
Hello, we pride ourselves in our service to our customers and have spent the last week looking into the initials E.S. Over the last year we've only had two customers with these initials but in reverse, no one that was E.S. … More
What reviewers keep mentioning
Topics Google extracted from this business’s reviews, with how many mention each. These are words that appeared in reviews, which is not the same as a service the business sells.
- siding15
- gutter replacement12
- professional crew11
- metal roof installation9
- storm damage repair8
- clean work area4
- new roof installation4
- professional installation3
- quality roofing3
- standing seam roof2
- shingle replacement2
Other reviews we hold
14 more of the 25 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.
- 5 out of 5Matt Claypoola week ago
We just had Gouge quality roofing completely replace our office roofing. They did a great job! Quality installation, clear communication, and a great crew. Would highly recommend them for any roofing work!
Reply from the business
Matt, thank you for the five-star review and kind words. We care about both our commercial and residential customers, and that lends itself to quality throughout. Please let us know if you have any other needs and, again, thank you.
- 5 out of 5Alex Macka week ago
Professional and Courteous. We had a problem with a previous contractor's work on a new rubber roof, and had Caleb out to take a look. …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
Reply from the business
Alex, thank you for the five-star review and the kind words. Because we care about serving our commercial and residential customers, it gives us the opportunity to be honest in assessing what needs to be done, and then doing it with quality throughout. Please let us know if there's anything else we can help with.
- 5 out of 5Ann Shannona week ago
Great customer service from everyone at this company!
Reply from the business
Ann, thank you for the five-star review and kind words. Because we care, it lends itself to great customer service and quality work throughout. Please let us know if you need anything else.
- 5 out of 5Kraig TayerEdited 2 weeks ago
Caleb and his crew did a topnotch job. They were asked to correct a poorly done job and did it with quality workmanship. He and is crew are very professional and conscientious in their work. Our new metal roof and siding they corrected …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
Reply from the business
Thank you so much for your kind words and thoughtful review! It means a lot to us that you trusted Gouge Quality Roofing to correct a previous job and allow us the opportunity to show what true craftsmanship looks like. We take great pride in delivering high-quality work with attention to detail, and we're thrilled to hear that you're happy with your new metal roof and siding. Your appreciation for excellent customer service really resonates with us, and we're grateful we could meet your expectations. Thanks again for the trust and support!
- 5 out of 5suzan sestito2 weeks ago
We are very proud of the work this company did to get our roof totally replaced. Glad we went with them.
Reply from the business
Suzan, thank you for the five-star review. Because we care for you, we put quality into everything we do, including your new roof. Please let us know if we can serve you in any other way.
- 5 out of 5Ben Harrison2 weeks ago
We had a great experience with Gouge Quality Roofing. Elijah worked with our insurance company to help us get our roof, siding, and gutters covered. Everything looks great and we appreciate the team’s professionalism and attention to detail. Would highly recommend.
Reply from the business
Ben, thank you for the five-star review. We're glad you had a great experience with our company and Elijah in particular, he's such a trusted guide for so many. We strive to be professional and serve others with quality and attention to detail, because we care for you.
- 5 out of 5Tammy Mooter3 weeks ago
We had a roof leak around my very large stone chimney. I am very pleased with the extensive work that needed to be done to do a proper permanent repair. Great communication about process and prompt service.
Reply from the business
Tammy, we were very pleased to serve you on this chimney repair. We strive to properly deliver the same level of quality repairs we would use on our own home, simply because we care. Please let us know if you need any other repairs or upgrades.
- 5 out of 5Tonya month ago
Jeff the salesman from Gouge was super helpful in dealing with our insurance company in getting them to pay for our 28 yr old roof after hail damage. Without his help we were looking at a very big expenditure. No other contractor we got …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
Reply from the business
Here at Gouge Quality Roofing, we truly care about our customers and love advocating for customers to receive quality products. Being polite and professional is at the center of what we do. We're so happy you're satisfied with your new roof. We're here to serve you in the future, and thank you for your recommendation.
- 5 out of 5RON EWELLa month ago
The materials that were installed are of great quality, but the customer service that I received is the game changer. They don't rush you and answer any questions with sincere interest and honesty. The installation crew were in and out …
Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.
Reply from the business
Providing high-quality materials is important to us, but we're especially grateful to hear that our team's customer service made the biggest impact. We believe every homeowner deserves honest communication, plenty of time to ask questions, and a stress-free experience from start to finish.
- 5 out of 5Bob Swishera month ago
I had gouge roofing repair some missing shingles. Matt inspected my roof and had to order the matching shingles. He did everything he said he would do and when he said he would do it. Tino did the work when the shingles came in. It was done with in a day or two of when they got them. I would use them again
Reply from the business
We truly appreciate your trust in Gouge Quality Roofing and are grateful for the opportunity to help with your roof repair. If you ever need roofing, siding, gutters, or any other exterior services in the future, we'd be happy to help. Thanks again for choosing Gouge Quality Roofing!
- 5 out of 5Kris Ruggles (Trailheadventures)a month ago
High-quality service
Reply from the business
Thank you for your 5-star review!
- 5 out of 5Rachel Beinea month ago
The team at Gouge did a great job walking us through the process, from helping us understand the insurance claim process, to a quick and easy installation, and quick and thorough fixing of an issue that came up with the dryer vent. Special thanks to Matt Notestone and Nate Arni for a job well done at our house!
Reply from the business
Thanks so much for taking the time to share your experience! We're thrilled to hear that our team made the entire process smooth and stress-free, from navigating the insurance claim to completing your roof installation. We know how important clear communication and quality workmanship are, and we're glad we could deliver on both.
- 5 out of 5Michael Oa month ago
From Jeff Blythe first visit to final inspection of my roof I've never encountered a more professional and thorough team. Don't hesitate to call on them for your Roofing needs. looking forward to their siding replacement.
Reply from the business
Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We're honored by your kind words and are thrilled to hear that you had such a positive experience from your first meeting with Jeff Bly through the final roof inspection. Providing professional service, clear communication, and quality workmanship is what we strive for on every project.
- 5 out of 5Karen Hartleya month ago
We had hail damage and were at the mercy of our insurance company until we spoke to Jeff. He and Gouge explained the insurance process and advocated for us and we ended up with a full roof replacement covered by insurance (vs. the initial offer of only 30%)
Reply from the business
Thank you so much for your kind review! We're glad Jeff was able to guide you through the insurance process and advocate on your behalf. Navigating an insurance claim after storm damage can be overwhelming, and our goal is to make the … More
The latest post from this business
Posted by Gouge Quality Roofing to their own Google profile 2 months ago. Their words, not ours.
“The team at Gouge did a great job walking us through the process, from helping us understand the insurance claim process, to a quick and easy installation, and quick and thorough fixing of an issue that came up with the dryer vent. Special thanks to Matt Notestone and Nate Arni for a job well done at our house!” -Rachel B. 19 hours agoBook
What Gouge Quality Roofing says about itself
Taken from the business’s own website. We have not checked any of it. These are quotes, not credentials — a roofer writing “licensed and insured” on their homepage is not evidence that they are.
Free estimates
“…Get a free quote Choose Gouge Quality Roofing: Central…”
Their site also states: warranty offered.
Other roofers in Lancaster
Ranked by how many ratings Google has counted.
| Roofing contractor | Google average | Ratings counted | One and two star | Contact |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Precision Roofing & Guttersgutter replacement, respectful staff, siding5.0275 ratings0.7% one and two star(740) 453-3649 | 5.0 | 275 | 0.7%2 of 275 | (740) 453-3649 |
| River Valley Restoration LLCsiding, insurance claim assistance, estimate4.6151 ratings8.6% one and two star(740) 272-5895 | 4.6 | 151 | 8.6%13 of 151 | (740) 272-5895 |
| Am Roofing And Siding LLCsiding, respectful crew, courteous staff4.987 ratings2.3% one and two star(740) 974-8268 | 4.9 | 87 | 2.3%2 of 87 | (740) 974-8268 |
| Clark's Straight Line Roofinggutters, workmanship, professional staff4.763 ratings7.9% one and two star(740) 654-9227 | 4.7 | 63 | 7.9%5 of 63 | (740) 654-9227 |
| AM Roofing and Siding LLCsiding replacement, polite crew, metal roof4.628 ratings7.1% one and two star(740) 974-8268 | 4.6 | 28 | 7.1%2 of 28 | (740) 974-8268 |
| Platinum Commercial Roofingon budget, commercial roofing, communication5.019 ratings0% one and two star(740) 505-0052 | 5.0 | 19 | 0%0 of 19 | (740) 505-0052 |
Where this page comes from
Every figure above is Google’s, captured on 24 September 2026. The star average and the 209 ratings behind it are counted by Google across all of its reviews. The review text on this page is a sample — we hold 28, of which 25 have any text — and it is not everything Google shows.
Roof Warden does not verify licenses, bonds, insurance or workers’ compensation cover, and nothing on this page should be read as though we had. Confirm those directly with the contractor and with your state or provincial licensing body before you hire anyone.