Skip to content
Roof Warden

Roofing contractor

Erie Home Roofing

4781 W Goodall St, Garden City, ID 83714

Google average
4.6
Ratings counted
76
One and two star
3 of 76(3.9%)
Idaho median
1.5%

The first three are Google’s own figures for Erie Home Roofing, read on 24 September 2026; the share is of every rating Google has counted, not of the review texts on this page. The median is ours — the middle figure among the Idaho roofers we list with enough ratings to compare.

Rating breakdown

4.6
76 ratings
How the 76 ratings break down, from five stars to one
5
6079%
4
1114%
3
23%
2
00%
1
34%
3.9%of these 76 ratings are one or two stars (3)

About typical — the typical roofer in Idaho sits at 1.5%. A higher share is a reason to read the critical reviews below, not a verdict.

The critical reviews

The one and two-star reviews, first. These are what a star average hides, and they are the reason this page exists.

All 3 of the one and two-star reviews we hold for Erie Home Roofing, most recent first.

  • 1 out of 5L. B6 months ago

    The absolute worst. DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY! Rebel roofing is wayyyyy better and doesn't use predatory tactics or invasive and aggressive sales methods. Literally sent me a rude text quoting me a random number well over $20k with zero explanation. Dangerous people if you are female. STAY AWAY FROM THIS COMPANY

    Reply from the business

    Hi, L.B. We are sorry to hear about your experience, but we thank you for sharing this with us. We care, and we want to make this better, please get in touch with us at 800-684-4628, we want to know more!

  • 1 out of 5Sam Morrisona year ago

    Cannot recommend based on experience with sales people. The sales people seemed fine at first and they did the inspection to see what needed to be done and how big the roofs were. After we started talking about products it felt like being …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    Thank you for sharing your concerns. We take your feedback seriously and apologize for any inconvenience caused. Please feel free to reach out to us at (800) 684-4628 to discuss this further.

  • 1 out of 5Sofia Pipera year ago

    Cannot speak for their work quality, however their “free” quote will cost you 4+ hours of your life.

    Reply from the business

    It's regrettable to hear about your experience. Please feel free to reach out to us at (800) 684-4628 to discuss further.

What reviewers keep mentioning

Topics Google extracted from this business’s reviews, with how many mention each. These are words that appeared in reviews, which is not the same as a service the business sells.

  • cost10
  • product quality9
  • efficient crew6
  • fast work6
  • roofing options5
  • material quality4
  • metal roofs2
  • informative staff2
  • tarps2
  • new roof2

Other reviews we hold

14 more of the 67 reviews we hold text for, most recent first. We do not hold every review Google has.

  • 5 out of 5ShihTzu Kennels (Tami Landon)Edited 3 months ago

    Erie Home Roofing are very professional and definitely care to make your roofing needs affordable. I could be more satisfied with a company who from planning to finish were the highest quality in all aspects. Very grateful for Erie Home.

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Shihtzu. We are thrilled to learn that you had a positive experience with us!

  • 5 out of 5LInda N “Wild One”4 months ago

    Very professional workers and clean up. Work done in a timely manner ever though the were battlng wind and working around rain. Impressed with the product installed provided by Erie Home.

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Linda. We are thrilled to learn that you had a positive experience with us!

  • 5 out of 5Norman Hasebe4 months ago

    Great job. Fast and professionally executed

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Norman. Thanks for taking the time to share your positive experience. We truly appreciate it!

  • 5 out of 5Mike Twitchell4 months ago

    Fast and professional service

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Mike. These words go a long way, it motivates us to work even harder, thank you for the review!

  • 4 out of 5Shauna Stevens5 months ago

    The workers were fantastic, they did an excellent job and cleaned up the area. I did find a few nails on the ground in strange places, but I know you do the best you can. The roof looks great! I like having a Warranty which we have never had before.

    Reply from the business

    We are pleased to hear our workers did excellent work and you love your new roof and warranty! If you need any extra cleanup done please call us at 800-684-4628!

  • 4 out of 5Alan Pack6 months ago

    In my area, Erie Homes acts as a general contractor that sub-contracts with local installers (roofing contractors). Erie did the scheduling and materials purchasing. Some of the materials are specific to Erie, hence their specific warranty. …

    Google cut this review short. The full text is on their Google profile.

    Reply from the business

    We are glad to hear our installers did excellent work and your roof looks great. Thank you for taking the time to submit a review, we really appreciate it!

  • 4 out of 5Sonny Thomas6 months ago

    Job was done quick and though, attention to detail. Any correction was done without question honoring warranty. Very pleased with the job performed.

    Reply from the business

    Your positive feedback means everything to us, Sonny. We're thrilled our quick, thorough work and warranty service exceeded your expectations.

  • 5 out of 5Matt Shutman9 months ago

    Very quick.

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Matt. We are thrilled to learn that you had a positive experience with us!

  • 4 out of 5Karen Petersen10 months ago

    Installation an clean up were professional and fast. My concerns were addressed immediately but we are not entirely satisfied with the result. The corners look rough where the roof and roofing fascia/ wood siding meet allowing insects or water access. We were told it has to be that way.

    Reply from the business

    Thank you for your review. We understand your concerns about the corners. Please contact us at (800) 684-4628 to discuss this further.

  • 5 out of 5Donald Heuer10 months ago

    The sales reps were very through and explained different options that would work for me. The roofing crew arrived early, was polite and efficient. My roof was completed in one day. Great team effort.

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Donald. Your feedback is highly appreciated. Thank you for the review!

  • 5 out of 5Laurie Acklin11 months ago

    Erie Home has great options for roofing. They have a great warranty. They hired a really great crew to do the work. They were very fast and efficient. They cleaned up the mess very nicely. Great experience all around.

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Laurie. Thank you so much for leaving us an A+ review!

  • 4 out of 5Sandy Smart11 months ago

    Loved the results from the new roof however, should have been told that the garage contents should have been covered with tarps because roofing residue and material was all over and was a mess.

    Reply from the business

    We are happy to hear you loved your new roof results. We apologize for not advising about garage protection beforehand.

  • 5 out of 5Richard Eagleston11 months ago

    I am happy to give Erie Home my Highest recommendation. Their presentation was professional and very informative. The quality of the product, including snow and ice shields was excellent and took into consideration for the difficulties of living in a mountain environment. The crew was a pleasure to work with. They worked very hard and good quality work. They made sure that all my concerns for sealing the roof before shingling were met. They cleaned the property daily and the final cleanup was excellent. The true test will be this next winter. I would be astonished If the new roof had any difficulties at all. Again, I would recommend Erie Home very strongly.

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Richard. We are thrilled to learn that you had a positive experience with us!

  • 5 out of 5jacob colea year ago

    Very professional, high quality materials and excellent customer service. My roof looks amazing

    Reply from the business

    Hi, Jacob. These words go a long way, it motivates us to work even harder, thank you for the review!

What Erie Home Roofing says about itself

Taken from the business’s own website. We have not checked any of it. These are quotes, not credentials — a roofer writing “licensed and insured” on their homepage is not evidence that they are.

  • Warranty offered

    “…Specials Design FAQs Financing Reviews Warranty All Locations Roofing Systems Metal…”

  • States a founding year

    “…Nationwide Service You Can Rely On Since 1976, Erie Home has installed premium home…”

  • Free estimates

    “…8-8301 Search for: Search Search Get My Free Estimate Get My Free Estimate Why Erie Home…”

  • Financing available

    “…Convenient Financing Available Investing in your home remodel is…”

  • Mentions the BBB

    “…Basement Waterproofing ★ ★ ★ ★ ★ Better Business Bureau They were considerate of my upstairs…”

Other roofers in Garden City

Ranked by how many ratings Google has counted.

Other roofers we list in Garden City
Roofing contractor
Idaho Roofing Contractorscleanup, answering questions, thoroughness4.9945 ratings1.3% one and two star(208) 921-7821
Lionheart Roofing Contractorsquick response, leak issue, drone inspection4.9114 ratings1.8% one and two star(208) 513-0353
Evergreen Exteriors, LLC Roofing, Sidingpunctuality, roof replacement, polite staff5.0105 ratings0% one and two star(986) 213-4967
Caliber Roofingprofessional crew, landscaping care, owner onsite5.095 ratings0% one and two star(208) 450-2121
Siding Pros of Idahosiding repair, product selection, fair pricing5.095 ratings1.1% one and two star(208) 672-1697
One Truss Roofing & Solarroof replacement, insurance claim assistance, easy to work with4.976 ratings1.3% one and two star(208) 872-2968

All roofers in Garden City →

Where this page comes from

Every figure above is Google’s, captured on 24 September 2026. The star average and the 76 ratings behind it are counted by Google across all of its reviews. The review text on this page is a sample — we hold 76, of which 67 have any text — and it is not everything Google shows.

Roof Warden does not verify licenses, bonds, insurance or workers’ compensation cover, and nothing on this page should be read as though we had. Confirm those directly with the contractor and with your state or provincial licensing body before you hire anyone.